Logo law and pluralism
Logo Università Bicocca

United States Supreme Court, No. 19-123, 17 June 2021

Date
17/06/2021
Type Judgment
Case number 19-123/2021
Link

Attachments

Abstract

Absence of discrimination of homosexual couples excluded, as potential foster families, from the placement of minors by a Catholic institution.

Normative references

First Amendment of the American Constitution

Ruling

The exclusion of same-sex couples as potential foster families for children is not discriminatory, since the religious freedom of the Catholic body entrusted with the management of the placement of children with foster families must prevail. By requiring the organization to choose between restricting the scope of the mission it pursues or accepting parental relationships that conflict with its convictions, the administration would place an excessive burden on the exercise of the organization’s religious freedom.