Logo law and pluralism
Logo Università Bicocca

Udo Steymann v. Staatssecretaris van Justitie, Case C-196/87, CJEU (Sixth Section), 5 October 1988

Date
05/10/1988
Type Judgment
Case number C-196/87

Abstract

Qualification of “economic activities” in relation to the participation of members of a religious community in commercial activities within the ambit of that community.

Normative references

Art. 10 EUCFR  
Art. 3 TUE  
Art. 56 TFEU 

Ruling

Commercial activities performed within a community based on religion or another spiritual or philosophical conception of life are to be considered as economic activities in so far as the services which the community provides to its members may be regarded as the indirect quid pro quo for genuine and effective work.
(The applicant Udo Steymann belonged to the Bhagwan Community (Rajneesh movement - Osho), a religious group that provided for the material needs of its members through commercial activities, including running a nightclub, bar and laundry. The community satisfied the needs of the followers regardless of the activities undertaken).