The failure to protect workers against dismissal for participating in a strike and the imposition of disproportionate criminal penalties for peaceful trade union activities may constitute a violation of Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights where restrictions on the exercise of trade union freedom are not justified and necessary in a democratic society.
Normative references
Art. 11 ECHR
Ruling
1. Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects trade union freedom, of which the right to strike is an essential element. Restrictions on the exercise of this freedom must be prescribed by law, pursue a legitimate aim and be necessary in a democratic society. Contracting States are also under a positive obligation to ensure its effective exercise in relations between private parties.
2. The dismissal of workers for participating in a strike, subsequently upheld by the domestic courts, may constitute a breach of the positive obligations arising under Article 11 ECHR where the decision is based on an insufficiently foreseeable interpretation of the conditions governing the lawfulness of strikes and is not accompanied by an adequate balancing of trade union freedom against the employer’s interests.
3. The imposition of criminal penalties on trade union representatives for organising peaceful picketing constitutes an interference with the freedom protected by Article 11 ECHR. Such interference cannot be regarded as necessary in a democratic society where it does not respond to a pressing social need and is disproportionate to the legitimate aim pursued, particularly in view of the potential “chilling effect” of the penalties on the exercise of trade union freedom.
Cookies
This site uses technical, analytics and third-party cookies. If you want to learn more or opt out of all or some cookies, press the "Manage cookies" button or consult the
Cookie policy