Logo law and pluralism
Logo Università Bicocca

United Kingdom Supreme Court, [2026] UKSC 8, 26 february 2026 (R v ABJ; R v BDN)

Abstract

Freedom of expression based on controversial political opinions, as protected by Article 10 ECHR, may be restricted where it encourages support for terrorist organisations.

Normative references

Section 12(1A) del Terrorism Act 2000

Art. 10 ECHR

Ruling

1. The offence under section 12(1A) of the Terrorism Act 2000, which criminalises the expression of opinions or beliefs supportive of a proscribed terrorist organisation, requires that the individual knowingly express an opinion objectively capable of demonstrating support for the organisation and be aware of the risk that such expression may encourage others to support it, unreasonably taking that risk in light of the circumstances known to them. It is not, however, necessary for the individual to be aware that the organisation has been proscribed.

2. Freedom of expression, particularly when exercised in the context of political debate on matters of public interest, also protects the expression of radical or controversial opinions, including those which coincide with views espoused by proscribed organisations. However, for the purposes of establishing the offence under section 12(1A) of the Terrorism Act 2000, a distinction must be drawn between sharing certain ideas, claims or political objectives and actually expressing support for the organisation as such. Mere ideological alignment is insufficient to constitute the offence, and the content of the expression must be assessed in its overall communicative context.

3. The prevention of terrorism and radicalisation constitutes a legitimate aim capable of justifying restrictions on freedom of expression under Article 10 par. 2 ECHR. The provision under section 12(1A) of the Terrorism Act 2000 does not constitute a disproportionate interference with the Convention right, since the definition of the constituent elements of the offence – and, in particular, the requirement to establish awareness of the risk of encouraging support for the proscribed organisation and the unreasonableness of taking that risk – ensures an appropriate balance between collective security requirements and the protection of individual freedoms. Accordingly, once all the elements of the offence have been established, no further, separate assessment of proportionality by the jury is required, without prejudice to the need for rigorous judicial scrutiny of the sufficiency of the evidence.